Jellibean Journals

Playtime activities, cloth diapers, and too many desserts!

  • About
    • ADVERTISE
  • RECIPES
  • PLAYTIME ACTIVITIES
  • CLOTH DIAPERING
  • Family Life
    • FAITH
    • TIPS & LIFEHACKS
    • SKINCARE
  • PREGNANCY & POSTPARTUM
    • PREGNANCY
    • POSTPARTUM
  • BLOG TIPS

Perfect Custard Pie

May 11, 2013 By Jelli 5 Comments

best custard pie recipeGrowing up in the Midwest, custard pie was one of my favorite picks at the local cafeteria. As a kid, I frequented these sit-down eateries brimming with gray-haired folk because my own grandparents were big believers in dining cafeteria-style. As far as creamy mashed potatoes and succulent slices of turkey breast go, I was just as convinced that no fast-food restaurant could ever take the place of good home-cooked cafeteria food– including the luscious assortment of pies.

Custard has always been one of my favorite down-home dessert picks, and custard pie a slightly more “upscale” presentation of a humble custard cup, speckled with spicy nutmeg. This creamy vanilla egg custard pie is gorgeously easy to make, satisfyingly sweet, and hard to keep your fork out of. Am I the only person who prods around in the pie pan “straightening out” the edges of pie slices with my fork as I prep the leftover pie for storage? Guilty.

Print
Perfect Custard Pie

Yield: 1-9\\\" pie

Perfect Custard Pie

Ingredients

  • Crust:
  • 1 1/3 c. flour
  • 1/2 t. salt
  • scant 1/2 c. shortening
  • 3 T. cold water
  • Pie Filling:
  • 3 eggs
  • 1 can (250g) evaporated milk
  • approx. 1/2 c. milk
  • 1 1/2 t. vanilla extract
  • 1/2 c. sugar
  • 2 T. flour
  • 1/4 t. salt
  • nutmeg, for sprinkling

Instructions

Crust:

Combine flour and salt in a large bowl. Cut in shortening using a pastry blender, or my favorite, your fingertips. Work it until the mixture resembles gravel. Pour in the water and stir with a sturdy spoon until dough will hold together when you try to form a ball. Less is more here. Stir too much and you'll wind up with a tough, chewy pie crust. Form dough into a disc and refrigerate as you preheat the oven to 350F. When oven reaches temperature, roll out the dough to fit your pie pan, prick with a fork, and bake 7 minutes. Remove from heat and reduce oven temp. to 325F.

Pie Filling:

Combine flour, sugar, and salt in a small bowl. Break one egg and add the white to a small dish and the yolk to a large bowl. Using a pastry brush, gently brush the egg white over the pie crust.

Pour remaining egg white into large bowl with the yolk. Add remaining eggs and vanilla. Pour evaporated milk into a measuring cup. Add enough milk (2% or whole) to bring the total milk to 2 c.and whisk this into the egg mixture.

Whisk dry ingredients into the milk+eggs slosh and pour into pie shell. Sprinkle with nutmeg to suit your fancy. I used about 2 teaspoons.

Bake for 1 hour or until custard is set. The center of the pie may not puff up as the edges, but as long as it's not jiggly, you're golden. Turn off oven and prop open oven door with a wooden spoon to allow pie to cool slowly for about 10 minutes. Then open the door and cool 10 min. more. Remove from oven and cool to room temp. before cutting. This slow cooling process is guaranteeing you a pie without cracks on top. If you don't mind cracked custard pie, just go ahead and cool the pie on a rack or on the countertop.Serve at room temperature or chilled. Store covered in the refrigerator.

3.1
https://jellibeanjournals.com/perfect-custard-pie/

Told you this was easy as, well…pie. Enjoy your newest taste treat! photo blogsignature_zps543c3e53.jpg

 

Follow on G+ | Like on Facebook | Tweet with me

 

 

Linking here: Marvelous Mon., Mop it up Mon., Tasty Tues., Works for me Weds., I’m lovin it, Create & Inspire, Weekend Wrap Up, Sundae Scoop

Filed Under: Recipes Tagged With: Pies and Tarts

About Jelli

Jelli is a blogging veteran and avid baker who’s been selling sweets to feed her chocolate addiction for 8+ years. When the polka dotted apron’s hanging up, she’s a full-time mama to three kidlets enjoying the crazy days of motherhood and pumping out brownie recipes from her sunny Costa Rican kitchen.

« Patchwork Waltz: Welcome, May!
Preparing Your Toddler for Potty Training // Mommy-Brain Mixer »

Comments

  1. Jenn says

    May 12, 2013 at 7:55 pm

    Sounds delicious!

    Reply
  2. Robin (Masshole Mommy) says

    May 15, 2013 at 5:46 am

    I haven’t had a custard pie in forever! This sounds so tasty!

    Reply
    • Jelli says

      May 15, 2013 at 8:47 am

      I hadn’t either. They’re so budget-friendly and lower in sugar than other pies, that I just couldn’t resist making it. Yum!

      Reply
  3. Kathy Penney @ Sparkles And A Stove says

    May 18, 2013 at 7:16 am

    I love custard pie! It looks delicious and your photo is great! If you’re linking up this weekend I’d love for you to show the pie off at All Things Pretty! http://sparklesandastove.com/all-things-pretty-linky-party-8/

    Reply
    • Jelli says

      May 18, 2013 at 8:45 am

      Thank you Kathy! Hope your weekend is great.

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Hi, I'm Jelli! I snagged the best guy around, birthed four tiny kidlets, scribble down too many dessert recipes, love Jesus, and grow veggies in my front yard. Read More…

  • Facebook
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter

Readers’ Favorite Recipes!

Homemade Croissants. Buttery, flaky and downright YUM! | JellibeanJournals.com
Easy homemade bagels | jellibeanjournals.com
Life-Changing Skinny Avocado Brownies- crave-worthy at a fraction of the calories and made from TWO ingredients! #brownies #lowcalorie #dessert from Jellibean Journals
Thin Mint Fudge- ready in five minutes! Jellibeanjournals.com
no bake snowball cookies
Easy Homemade DARK Chocolate Pudding | Jellibeanjournals.com
Link Party Recommendations
Privacy Policy & Disclosures
Seasoned Pro Responsive Minimalist Food Blog Theme

Copyright © 2025 · Jellibean Journals